Can Charges Be Dropped Before Trial in Arkansas?

by | Mar 4, 2026 | Criminal Law

Yes. An Arkansas criminal charge can end before trial through a prosecutor’s dismissal approved by the court or a court ruling on a valid legal ground. An eligible case can also reach dismissal through a deferred disposition. But “dropped” does not necessarily mean the charge is permanently gone or the record is sealed. The particular charge, legal basis, and written order matter.

Who Can Drop Criminal Charges?

The prosecutor decides whether to ask to stop pursuing a charge. Arkansas law requires the court’s permission and an entry in the court record. A prosecutor’s decision not to proceed is called nolle prosequi, sometimes shortened to “nol pros.” It ends the pending prosecution without itself deciding whether you are guilty.

The alleged victim cannot dismiss the charge personally. The prosecutor must confer with the victim before dismissing charges or making certain other disposition decisions, but consultation does not give the victim control over the prosecution. See what happens when the alleged victim wants charges dropped.

Ark. Code §§ 16-85-713, 16-89-122, and 16-21-106(b).

Different Outcomes Have Different Consequences

Outcome What It Means
Nolle Prosequi The pending prosecution ends. Refiling can remain possible, subject to legal limits.
Dismissal That Bars Further Prosecution A valid legal ground, such as an established speedy-trial violation requiring dismissal, prevents another prosecution of the covered charge.
Reduced-Charge Plea A negotiated reduction can still result in a conviction. Dismissal of one count does not erase a conviction on another.
Deferred Disposition An authorized procedure postpones adjudication while you meet conditions. Entry into the program is not the final dismissal order.

An acquittal is different: it is a determination of not guilty, including a trial ruling that the evidence is legally insufficient. A prosecutor’s pretrial dismissal does not provide the same protection against another prosecution.

Ark. Code §§ 5-1-112(1), 16-89-122, and 16-93-303; Ark. R. Crim. P. 25.3 and 30.1; Evans v. Michigan, 568 U.S. 313 (2013).

Evidence Problems Can Support A Request To End The Case

Your lawyer can present concrete reasons for the prosecutor to reconsider the charge. The useful question is which part of the accusation the evidence fails to support:

  • Identity. Does video, location information, or a documented timeline contradict the identification of you as the person involved?
  • A required element. Does the proof establish the alleged act, required mental state, or another fact the charged offense requires?
  • Witness reliability. Does a recording contradict a material part of the account? Did the witness actually observe the event?
  • New evidence. Does a laboratory result, complete message thread, or newly located recording change what the earlier report appeared to show?

At trial, the State must prove every element beyond a reasonable doubt. But a missing physical exhibit or a conflict between witnesses does not automatically defeat the case. Testimony can establish an offense, and credibility disputes can remain for the judge or jury to resolve.

Ark. Code § 5-1-111(a); Overton v. State, 2025 Ark. 105.

What A Judge Can Decide Before Trial

A motion saying “the State’s evidence is weak” is not a substitute for trial. Arkansas does not authorize a preliminary hearing to test the probable cause supporting a filed felony information and then dismiss it for lack of probable cause. A pretrial motion needs an applicable legal ground, rather than simply a request to decide whose account is true.

Nance v. State, No. CR94-413 (Ark. Mar. 4, 1996).

Suppression Of Illegally Obtained Evidence

A motion to suppress asks the court to exclude particular evidence. Under Rule 16.2, suppression requires a substantial violation or a constitutional requirement to exclude the evidence. Winning the motion does not itself dismiss the charge; the remaining admissible proof still matters.

The motion must be timely and filed no later than ten days before the scheduled trial, unless the court allows a later filing for good cause. Give counsel the search, arrest, and interview details early enough to investigate and meet that deadline.

Ark. R. Crim. P. 16.2(b), (e).

Discovery Violations

Late or missing criminal discovery does not automatically require dismissal. Rule 19.7 allows the court to order disclosure, grant a continuance, exclude undisclosed material, or enter another appropriate order. Counsel should identify what was withheld, the violation, and why the requested remedy addresses the problem.

Ark. R. Crim. P. 19.7.

Speedy-Trial Violations

In an initial prosecution, a defendant released on bond has a twelve-month trial period measured from arrest or service of summons, extended by authorized exclusions. Defense continuances and qualifying periods involving pretrial proceedings can affect the calculation. Counting calendar months alone is not enough.

A qualifying violation can require dismissal with an absolute bar to further prosecution. The motion must be raised before trial or a guilty plea to avoid waiver under the rule. The separate nine-month rule for a defendant held in a city or county jail concerns release pending trial, after authorized exclusions; it does not itself require dismissal.

Ark. R. Crim. P. 28.1, 28.2, 28.3, and 30.1.

Can The State File The Charge Again?

A pretrial nolle prosequi does not itself bar refiling. Two different timing rules can limit another prosecution:

Statute Of Limitations

The deadline to commence prosecution varies by offense, and some offenses have no limitation period. Time during a pending Arkansas prosecution for the same conduct is excluded. Counsel needs the offense date and the arrest, summons, warrant, and charging history.

Speedy Trial

A prosecutor’s nolle prosequi does not automatically start a fresh twelve-month period. Rule 28.3(f) excludes the time between dismissal and refiling only for good cause shown. The original case’s dates and excluded periods still matter.

Preserving an objection matters too. When the defense has notice and an opportunity to object, waiting until refiling to challenge the lack of good cause can be too late. Keep the original docket, dismissal motion, order, and hearing record so counsel can establish what happened.

Ark. Code §§ 5-1-109 and 16-89-122; Ark. R. Crim. P. 28.3(f); Hoover v. State, 2022 Ark. App. 188.

A Deferred Disposition Requires More Than A Promise Of Probation

Act 346 is one possible deferred-disposition route. It requires eligibility, your consent, and court approval. You must have no prior felony conviction and cannot have used Act 346 before. The procedure begins with a guilty or no-contest plea before adjudication of guilt and probation for at least one year, subject to the court’s authority to release you early.

Fulfilling the conditions or receiving an authorized early release leads to discharge and a dismissal order; sealing remains subject to the applicable restrictions. A violation can lead to an adjudication of guilt. Even after successful completion, the disposition can count for criminal-history and sentencing purposes. Eligibility alone does not require the judge to offer Act 346. Have counsel identify the exact procedure and written terms before you plead.

Ark. Code §§ 16-93-302(a) and 16-93-303(a)-(d).

DWI Has Separate Restrictions

For a DWI charge under § 5-65-103, § 5-65-107 prohibits reduction or dismissal through ordinary charge bargaining, and § 5-65-108 excludes Act 346. Those restrictions do not eliminate valid constitutional or procedural defenses, including a properly established speedy-trial violation. Read when a DWI can be dismissed in Arkansas before assuming a general criminal-case option applies.

After Dismissal, Confirm What The Order Actually Resolves

Get the entered order and check each count. Confirm whether anything remains pending and which appearances or restrictions still apply. Don’t assume a discussion about dismissal has canceled a court date or changed another court’s order.

Dismissal alone does not automatically seal the record. For a qualifying case under § 16-90-1410, a petition to seal a nolle prosequi disposition must wait one year from entry of that order. That year is a sealing waiting period, not the State’s deadline to refile. An ordinary dismissal has a different sealing route under the same statute, without that one-year wait. See Arkansas record-sealing options.

Ark. Code § 16-90-1410.

What To Bring To A Case Review

  • Charging papers, release orders, and court notices. These identify the exact allegations, deadlines, and conditions.
  • Complete messages, original recordings, and a timeline. Preserve context and identify camera locations promptly so relevant recordings can be requested before they disappear.
  • Prior dismissal orders and case records. These help determine refiling limits, excluded time, and whether an earlier disposition affects program eligibility.
  • Any written offer or proposed program terms. These show whether the proposal actually provides dismissal, when that would occur, and what you must do first.

Understand Your Options Before Trial

I’m Wesley Rhodes, a criminal defense attorney in Little Rock. I can review the charge, evidence, court deadlines, and any proposed resolution with you. Call 501-301-4591 for a free consultation.

Schedule a Free Consultation

Updated October 29, 2026

This blog post is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading this content does not create an attorney-client relationship with Wesley Rhodes, Attorney at Law. If you need legal advice about your specific situation, you should consult with a qualified criminal defense attorney.